Choosing the right roof shingles can be a big decision for homeowners, especially when cost is a key factor. Among the many brands available, CertainTeed and Atlas are two of the most commonly compared. Both offer asphalt shingles with solid reputations, but their pricing and features vary enough to make homeowners ask: which one is more budget-friendly?
This article breaks down the key cost differences between CertainTeed vs Atlas shingles, helping homeowners understand where their money goes and what to expect long-term.
A Look at CertainTeed and Atlas Roofing Brands
CertainTeed
CertainTeed is often seen as a premium brand in the roofing industry. Their products, such as Landmark, Landmark Pro, and Presidential Shake, are known for thicker construction, high wind resistance, and long warranties. Many roofing contractors consider CertainTeed a top-tier option, especially for homeowners looking for long-term durability and enhanced protection.
Atlas Roofing
Atlas focuses on value-driven roofing with strong features at competitive prices. Their most popular lines include Pinnacle Pristine and StormMaster. Atlas shingles often include Scotchgard protection against algae streaks, which comes standard in many products. Homeowners looking for both performance and affordability may find Atlas appealing.
Material Cost Comparison
When comparing material prices, Atlas generally comes in lower than CertainTeed. Here’s a breakdown of average prices per square (100 square feet):
CertainTeed Landmark: around $90 to $120 per square
Atlas Pinnacle Pristine: around $80 to $100 per square
Premium shingles from either brand, like Landmark Pro or StormMaster Shake, can cost more, reaching up to $130–$150 per square in some markets.
The price gap may not seem huge at first, but across an entire roof, even $10–$20 per square can add up to hundreds or thousands of dollars in difference.
Installation Costs
Labor costs for installing roof shingles vary by location and contractor. On average, both brands take a similar effort to install. However, there are a few key points that can affect the total installation price:
CertainTeed: For full warranty protection, CertainTeed often requires installation by certified contractors. These professionals may charge higher rates due to training and quality requirements.
Atlas: In many cases, Atlas shingles are easier to install and may require fewer specialized steps, which could lower labor costs slightly.
In short, while the shingles themselves differ in price, the difference in labor costs depends more on the contractor than the brand.
Warranty and Long-Term Value
One area where CertainTeed stands out is its warranty structure. CertainTeed offers extended warranties like SureStart Plus, which can provide up to 50 years of protection when installed by certified contractors. This kind of coverage adds peace of mind and could help avoid expensive repairs down the road.
Atlas also offers strong warranties, especially on their Scotchgard-protected shingles. While Atlas warranties are competitive, they may not be quite as extensive in coverage as CertainTeed’s.
When looking at long-term value, the higher upfront cost of CertainTeed shingles may pay off over time, especially in areas with harsh weather or for homeowners planning to stay in their home for many years.
Performance and Features for the Price
When comparing CertainTeed vs Atlas shingles, it’s clear both brands offer good performance, but they appeal to different priorities.
CertainTeed shingles are thicker and heavier, adding resistance to wind, impact, and wear. These features can justify the higher price tag for many homeowners.
Atlas shingles focus on value without sacrificing quality. For instance, Pinnacle Pristine has built-in algae resistance and high wind ratings, all at a lower price point.
Homeowners looking for solid performance on a budget may lean toward Atlas, while those wanting the most protection possible may prefer CertainTeed.
Climate and Location Considerations
Where a home is located plays a role in choosing the right shingles. For example:
Atlas shingles work well in humid or rainy areas because of their Scotchgard technology, which helps prevent black streaks caused by algae growth.
CertainTeed shingles may be better suited for regions with frequent storms, high winds, or colder temperatures due to their sturdy build and high impact ratings.
Choosing the right product may depend less on cost and more on what’s needed to handle local weather conditions.
Budget vs. Features: What Matters Most to Homeowners?
For some, saving money upfront is the top priority. In that case, Atlas shingles provide reliable performance and a cleaner appearance at a more affordable price. For others, long-term protection and fewer future repairs may justify paying more for CertainTeed’s premium products.
It’s also worth noting that professional contractors can often give detailed estimates for both brands. A side-by-side quote makes it easier to compare total project costs, including installation, underlayment, and disposal of old roofing.
Which Shingle Brand Offers the Best Value for Your Budget?
When comparing CertainTeed vs Atlas shingles, both brands have their strengths. Atlas tends to be more budget-friendly upfront, offering solid features for the price. CertainTeed may cost more, but it provides added durability, stronger warranties, and a reputation for lasting quality.
In the end, the right choice depends on the homeowner’s goals, budget, and location. Getting quotes from local roofing professionals, reviewing warranty options, and thinking about long-term value are key steps in picking the right roof shingles.
